Championship Point Deductions – Are They Fair?

We thought it might be fun to take a look at the point deductions handed out by FNSW at the start of the year for various administrative issues.

9 clubs were handing point deductions (10 if you count Wagga) with 8 of them being a 30 point Championship reduction and one 15 point reduction.

Now, is it fair to punish the players, coaches, TDs for administrative/compliance errors? We would argue no. However, we do understand the need for strict compliance, although we feel a fine may have sufficed for the most part.

In the NPL 2 competition Bonnyrigg copped a 30 point reduction to start the season and it took them a few weeks to get into the positives.

With the 30 points back they would be 55 points behind the leaders, and have a sniff at promotion. It may have also altered the mindset of the club without the monkey on their back, and may have boosted them further up.

There is no denying though that the additional 30 points would guarantee them safety at this point, and it would have been very harsh to be relegated for compliance issues left over from the previous board.

In the NPL 3 competition 5 teams were hit with reductions and for the most part it seemed as though they would be the 5 to be relegated. Alas Stanmore have bucked that trend, however the additional 30 points would put them 2nd in the Club Championship standings with a real shot at promotion.

Whilst the extra points wouldn’t have helped WNSW or Rage, Parramatta and Hawksebury really could use them right now. 30 extra points would but the Hawks 1 point behind Dully with safety in their sights, whilst Parramatta would be better situated to fight for their safety and against a never before seen triple relegation.

Again we understand that the Parramatta issues occured from a previous board.

Finally in the State League, none of the 3 sides that received reductions will come anywhere close to promotion, however with points being allocated based on CC finishing over the last 3 years, there is the possibility that a club like Balmain may lose a point for a slightly worse finish, however we don’t believe it will be an issue for them.

In all we believe that FNSW were wrong in handing out point deductions for admin errors, and it certainly may come back to bite some teams in the rear.

One Comment

  1. Dave

    August 3, 2019 at 12:22 am

    This decision has already destroyed the season for some clubs and may well destroy some clubs. There has already been a substantial fine, the sanction imposition has been advertised for a full seasons, caused sponsorship problems and player acquisition difficulties and now it looks like relegation for most of the clubs. All this because a legally not required document could not be provided in time. The application process was set up to ensure there were failures, that when combined with multiple team relegations is untenable, especially as the 14 team competitions were implemented by FNSW to allow HAL Club entry and stop a branch from being relegated to state league. Is this good governance, maybe this needs being bought to the public’s attention via the media.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.